A Good Reminder
An interesting observation set inside a gripe about the BBC mindset. In the middle of this essay (worth reading) comes a section that resonates:
Obviously all institutions have to be watched pretty closely. Although their justification lies in the service they provide, their fundamental objective has always been self-preservation. Without their critics, 10-year-old children would still be going up chimneys, women would not be able to vote, and sheep-stealers would still be being hanged. Nevertheless they are all that stands between the civilised world and the chaos of anarchy or the violence of tyranny.
It would have been more than reasonable for us to have opposed specific abuses by institutions; homosexual acts were decriminalised during my BBC years, which we all applauded. But the focus of our hostility was the institutions themselves.
Institutions are made of people. People, being human, will screw up every thing they touch; but that said, they still are made of people. Institutions are better understood when one knows the people in the institution, to better know how the institutional culture is built. Then one can better deal with, support, or destroy the institution as necessary.
2 Responses to “A Good Reminder”
Trackback URL for A Good Reminder: http://gmapalumni.org/chapomatic/wp-trackback.php?p=2557
July 21st, 2007 at 5:11 am
Yah, *neurotypical* people, which stands to reason, they being something like 99% of the population.
Most NTs are kinda Ok, I guess, but the ones who succeed in bureaucratic institutions seem to be outliers at playing the bullying social dominance game, and I mean they are playing to *win*
The Armed Forces don’t seem quite so bad, maybe because of the occasional Live Ammo Reality Test.
July 21st, 2007 at 5:19 am
Oh yeah, and being a submariner, I reckon you know how real and unnatural being deep under water can be.
I think one of Niven’s Laws warns about the dangers of unnatural fun. Mother Nature would be happy to squash any of us like a bug, at any time, for any reason or no reason.
It sure is fun to cheat Nature at times, though.